Dine-In – When you come in to our store, you will be enticed by the wonderful aroma of cheese and bread. Our customers did not want to leave, so we started feeding them. In addition to all of our retail products, we offer a lovely menu of gourmet selections for you to eat right in our warm and bright store. Stop-in for a small flight and a cup of coffee or tea.
Free Wifi is available to customers.
Take-Out – We offer a variety of wholesome prepared foods made for your guests enjoyment. Menu items contain products available in our store, or sourced locally. Please Call -In your order with 2-3hrs advance for large parties.
Flights
Let your taste buds take a flight of fancy with one of our feature samplings for individuals or small groups. A single flight ($7/$9) offers you three cheeses, meats, and bread, crackers, nuts, or fruits. A double flight ($14/$18)offers your twice the fun, with six cheeses and all the above. All products are matched to give you the most enticing flavor experience.
Wisconsin Flight – Cheeses from our WI collection, locally baked baguettes or artisan flatbreads, WI summer sausage, and local preserves or honey.
American Flight – Cheeses from our American collection (including WI), with BSM Dried Fruit mix and other complementary products from around the U.S.
International Flight – Cheeses from our unique European collection, dried Salami, marcona almonds, imported olives and a baguette.
Group Flights – Got a bigger group looking for a special place to visit and enjoy great cheese?
Try a couple flights for 2 and a great pot of French pressed coffee!
Cheese Trays
Each tray order is taken by our staff with your guests in mind. We build each tray individually, cheeses are cut by hand, and matched with complements to suit and enhance cheese flavors. Our trays are offered in International, American or Wisconsin cheese themes.
Small Tray – Two sizes fit this category: Intimate – This tray feeds a small group of your closest cheeselovers, from 4 to 6 appetites; complete with 3 ¼# pieces of cheese and our BSM dried fruit mix. $15
Friends and Family – Need to feed a bigger group? 3 ⅓# pieces of cheese, BSM dried fruit mix and Spanish Cocktail Mix. $25
Medium Tray – Whew! Having a family birthday party with the inlaws? This tray will supply a great sampling for the crowd of 16 – 20 with 5 cheeses, crackers, BSM dried fruit mix, and nuts or Spanish Cocktail Mix. $35
Large Tray – Wow! The neighborhood is having a PARTY! And you are in charge of the appetizers! This tray features 7 cheeses, charcuterie, BSM dried fruit mix, crostini or crackers, and Spanish cocktail mix. $45
Hosting Tools and Tips – Our cheeses are fresh and delicious, so yes, the trays do need to be refrigerated until 30 minutes before your party begins! At that point, all you need to do is set it out to warm to room temperature and watch your guests dig in to flavor!
Sandwich Tray – Featuring a deli style w/roast beef, turkey, and ham w/ WI Swiss, Cheddar, or Provolone Cheese – *Breads used will be rye, rustic white and 12 grain *Turkey Sandwich comes with only lettuce while other sandwiches come with tomato as well *Condiments are included in side dishes – mayo/mustard
Included in large takeout orders: Small/Large Sandwich plates and forks. 1 3# bowl of salad (Coleslaw, Broccoli Slaw, or Oriental), Feeds approx. 20 people at ½ sandwich each
Sandwiches
Popping your sandwich in the oven to melt the cheese before putting it together serves to fold the accompanying meat and vegetables in a sensation of flavor! We toast all sandwiches eaten in the store, so they are warm, melty, juicy!
The Rye Wrangler – A perfect sandwich for your cowboy! Slices of top round on hearty rye bread with your choice of 2 year aged swiss or blue cheese with tomato, lettuce, and mustard.
The Colonist – Ben Franklin would have been proud! A smoked turkey on 12 grain bread with Hook’s Baby Swiss cheese and cranberry cherry salsa with lettuce.
The Statesman – A nod to our founding fathers! Virginia ham and Hook’s cheddar melted on rustic country wheat bread with mustard, with lettuce and tomato.
The Dane – For the non-meat lover! Creamy WI havarti with dill melted on rye bread with mustard, tomato and lettuce.
The Don – The ultimate flight of fancy on bread! Layered slices of prosciutto, 3 month old Manchego cheese, and quince preserves toasted between two slices of rustic country wheat with lettuce.
Soups
Our soups are crafted for chefs in the classic French culinary tradition, and end in a line of restaurant quality soups that are hearty and full of natural ingredients. Call for our daily soup selection!
Wisconsin Cheese
Vegetarian Tomato Basil
Santa Fe Tortilla
Black Forest Lentil
Corn & Red Pepper Chowder
Included: Saltine type crackers are included ( We provide Crunchy Crust Crackers – a wheat cracker, a little heartier than the typical saltine).
Included in large takeout orders: Soup cups/bowls and soup spoons 8# bag ‘o soup = 32 servings Feeds approx 25 people
Salad
Cafe Market Salad – a simple (seasonal greens), carrot, and other seasonal cut veggies in a salad. Dressed with either a golden italian or a cataline dressing. $5/$3.50
Cafe Mediterranean Salad - romaine lettuce topped with feta cheese and kalamata olives. Dressed with a golden italian dressing. $5/$3.50
Cafe Blue - Mixed greens, blue cheese crumbles, green apple slices and walnuts dressed with catalina dressing. $5/$3.50
Included in large takeout orders: Croutons, tomato, red onion, Small plates/bowls for salad & forks, napkins Feeds approx 5 people per lb
Occasional Items
Pita Pizza – a unique store creation in flavors like Mediterranean with feta, fontina, spinach and Kalamata olives or Continental with Comte cheese, spinach, and roasted red peppers!
Drinks and Spirits
Soda – We offer a distinct line of flavored sodas (GuS- the Grownup Soda) or Artisan iced teas!
Coffee and Tea – We offer hot French pressed coffees or teas for your enjoyment.
Beer and Wine - By the glass – $5 for our monthly house selection, $6 for our Wine Club Selection. $4 for a bottle of New Glaurus beer. $3 corkage fee added to wine selected from our vault.
Our staff will be happy to help you make the perfect cheese and wine match!